CREAM CHEESES — CLOSEST TO HOMEMADE®

May 2023

Although only a few of us ever make homemade Cream Cheese, it consists of just four ingredients:

PHILADELPHIA CREAM CHEESE is the #1 U.S. Cream Cheese

Although both are designated as “Original”, the Philadelphia Original Cream Cheese in the Brick — below left — has five ingredients while there are 13 ingredients in Philadelphia Original Whipped Cream Cheese Spread — below right.

Philadelphia Original in the Brick is not certified as Closest To Homemade because it contains added Carob Bean Gum which is Not In Kitchen™ when making homemade Cream Cheese.

WHEYS and GUMS in the SPREAD: Added to give the product a softer, spreadable consistency.

PRESERVATIVES in the SPREAD: Added to keep the product fresher longer since the Cream Cheese has greater exposure to oxygen while it is in use; once the lid is open, the entire surface is exposed to oxygen and the lid usually stays off for a minute or more. (Source for ingredients: Kraft Heinz Philadelphia Cream Cheese Web site 5/23)

Here’s a comparison of Philadelphia Cream Cheese to Walmart Great Value Cream Cheese:

Seen below, these Flavored Philadelphia Cream Cheese Spreads contain way more than just the ingredient noted in the flavor descriptor including added Sugar:

Following are some Cream Cheeses which contain added Gum(s):

Here’s a closer look at what’s inside two of the brands just noted >> Whole Foods 365 and Private Label Cream Cheese from Giant stores contain the exact same ingredients but Whole Foods 365 costs 50¢ more for an 8oz. package:

CLOSEST TO HOMEMADE: Following are some Cream Cheeses made with only the type of ingredients we would use at home. These include offerings from the Sierra Nevada Cheese Company, Russ & Daughters based in Manhattan, and Nancy’s with added Probiotic Cultures.

*Neither money nor products are ever accepted to appear on the Closest To Homemade list*

Discover more food + beverages whose ingredients are Closest To Homemade in 275+ categories. Neither money nor products are ever accepted to appear on the Closest To Homemade list.

Closest To Homemade® Master List

Contact and follow us at: